The Department of Justice has asked a federal judge to order Google to hand over data showing millions of searches. The data is not needed for a criminal investigation, but to help the DoJ prove its case that a Child Protection Law is sound.
Basically, the government is asking Google to do its research for free, even if it means Google has to violate its own privacy policy. Other major search engines, including Yahoo and MSN, have already complied with the DoJ request. Everyone already knew they did not care about user privacy, as they had previously helped the Chinese government track down a blogger who had posted items critical of Chinese leadership. That blogger was arrested, and is still behind bars.
Google's refusal of the government request shows that there are still things bigger than the Bush administration, such as American ideals of freedom and rights such as protection from unlawful search and seizure. This request has nothing to do with upholding the law, as the Bush administration just wants the data to help it pass a law that is not currently on the books. There is no reason why Google should be forced to comply with that request. Companies do not have an obligation to support the legislation brought forth by a president or political party. Just because the Republicans are in charge of the White House, Congress, and Supreme Court does not mean that they can ignore the law. People and businesses still have rights in this country, no matter who is in charge.
Bush Administration Demands Search Data; Google Says No, Yahoo